Pushed Too Far

  PUSHED TOO FAR

  A THRILLER

  Ann Voss Peterson

  Everyone has a breaking point …

  Introduction

  As a reader, there is nothing I love more than the chill of a cold, atmospheric thriller. It’s why I’ve seen the film FARGO and read Scott B. Smith’s classic A SIMPLE PLAN more times than I care to admit. It’s the icy claustrophobia of the small-town Midwest in the dead of winter, that when channeled right, makes for something special—the best crime fiction in the world.

  This standalone novel by Ann Voss Peterson, PUSHED TOO FAR, is that kind of special, and its heroine, Val Ryker, Chief of Police of tiny Lake Loyal, Wisconsin, is one for the ages. When the victim of a prior murder that rocked the village inexplicably turns up, the man incarcerated for her killing, an undisputed monster, is released from prison with a hell of a grudge, intent on holding Ryker and everything she loves to the fire.

  PUSHED TO FAR is not only a first-rate thriller, not only a police-procedural written with absolute authority by a writer who knows her stuff, but most of all, most importantly, it’s a portrait of Police Chief Ryker, a woman of extraordinary courage who is pushed beyond her breaking point.

  Good thrillers put their characters through the wringer. Great ones rain down holy hell upon their heads—physically, emotionally, psychologically—and aren’t satisfied until the reader is spent, exhilarated, terrified, and lavishly entertained.

  This is a great thriller, and with it, Peterson has firmly established herself as a major league talent and a must-read writer.

  Enjoy!

  -Blake Crouch, March 2012

  Chapter

  One

  David Lund had trained for this moment and visualized it a thousand times. But his legs still vibrated as he toed off his shoes and pushed a stocking foot into yellow rubber.

  He shook the thermal suit and worked his foot deeper, finally seating it into the attached boot. Shoving his other foot home, then pulling the suit up his torso, he squinted at the skin of ice covering much of Lake Loyal.

  He couldn’t see a damn thing.

  Not a spot of colorful clothing, not a dark shape against the flat expanse of gray. But a police officer on a routine patrol of the park reported a woman had fallen through the ice. And she wouldn’t last long. Not in Wisconsin’s early December chill.

  He had to hurry.

  Activity buzzed around him, fellow firefighters, EMTs, cops yelling out orders, getting into position. They all had their role, a well-oiled machine.

  He only hoped it would be enough.

  Lund shimmied his shoulders into the suit, tucked in his sweatshirt, and pulled the hood over his head. The rubber was meant to fit tightly, to protect him from frigid water. Once finished dressing, he’d be encased in yellow and black, only his eyes and nose showing. He could float in the lake for hours, buoyed by the air left in the suit, his own body heat protecting him from the chill.

  Of course, getting into the damn thing was a trick bordering on magic.

  Dempsey and Johnson raced past, carrying the pontoon raft from Unit One to shore, their boots crunching on the frozen pea gravel path circling the lake. Wind thrashed leafless trees and spun the merry-go-round in the park, as if it were ridden by ghosts.

  Lund raised the zipper as high up his chest as he could, then stuffed his arms into the sleeves.

  The newest addition to the Lake Loyal PD, a part-time cop named Schoenborn, ran up the sloping shoreline toward him, her cheeks pink with the cold.

  “You see her?” he asked. “I can’t from here.”

  “You’ll spot her when you get on the water. She’s just on the other side of that clump of cattails. I haven’t seen her move.” Her voice soared to a higher pitch than usual, making the rookie seem even younger than Lund suspected she was.

  “You the first one here?”

  “Yeah.” Wind tore a few dark strands from her ponytail and whipped them across her face. “After I called it in, all I could do was wait. I’ve never felt so useless in my life.”

  Lund had tasted that feeling more often than he wanted to admit. He’d like to tell her it would be all right, but sometimes people couldn’t be saved, no matter how much you wanted it, no matter how hard you tried. If anyone knew that, it was him.

  He pushed his hands into the attached rubber mitts and eyed the cop. “If you want to feel useful, you can help zip me up.”

  She sprang toward the zipper and worked on tugging and tucking until it was up to his neck.

  A second later, Dempsey joined them, lending his experienced hands to the task. “Okay, let’s get some of this air out, and you’re good to go.”

  Lund crouched into a ball, the suit puffing up around him like a balloon.

  The weathered firefighter patted him down, pushing out the extra air. He snugged the zipper the remaining inches over Lund’s chin, pulling the rubber hood tight around his face until only his nose and eyes were exposed to the cold. “That’s as good as it’s going to get.”

  Lund stood, the suit sucking to him like thick plastic wrap. His breath rasped in his ears, the sound magnified by the hood.

  Dempsey clipped the tow rope to Lund’s back, and he started down to shore feeling every ridge and bump of the frozen ground through the rubber boots, as if walking outside in socks. He stepped carefully. A tear would only slow him down, force him to start over with another suit, and he had no time to lose.

  The woman couldn’t last long in the freezing water. Her body would shut down, muscles refusing to move, reflexes slowing until she could no longer stay afloat and sank under the slushy waves.

  But in cold water, drowning didn’t necessarily mean death.

  For about an hour after breathing stopped, maybe more, she could be rescued and revived without suffering brain damage. Lund wasn’t sure how long the victim had been in the lake, but if there was a chance of pulling her out within that golden hour, he would grab it.

  The ice rimming the lake was thick enough to support weight, and Lund skidded out to the spot where the pontoon raft rested. A tow rope connected it to the firefighters on shore, just like the one on his belt, enabling Dempsey and Johnson to tow him back once he had secured the woman to the raft.

  Until then, it was up to him.

  The rescue craft was made up of two foam board pontoons with an aluminum tube rail running along each. Leaning forward, he grasped the rails, stepped into the space between, and shuffled over the ice, carrying the raft as if driving Fred Flintstone’s car.

  Twenty feet from open water the surface started to creak beneath his feet.

  He took a step, then another, his third plunged through, water over the ankle.

  He lifted onto the raft, straddling the open water and bracing the outsides of his knees against the rails. The lake rolled and shifted under him, chunks of ice and swirls of water. He grabbed the paddle from its clamp and dug into the slush between bright orange pontoons, moving out into the lake.

  Squinting against the wind, he could see her now, between the remnants of cattails and open water, just where the cop had indicated. Light pink jacket. Long brown hair encrusted with ice. The victim wasn’t moving—no flailing, no struggling—just lying face down in the water, bobbing with the movement of the waves.

  Shit.

  He paddled hard, the burn settling into his arms, his shoulders. Shifting side to side, he used his weight to steer toward the woman like a kid riding a skateboard.

  Unconscious?

  Dead?

  How much time had passed since she entered the water? What in the hell had she been doing this far out on thin ice?

  Sweat slicked his back. His throat ached with the chill air, his ears, his jaw. He pushed his muscles, closi
ng the last few yards.

  A foot or two away, he fitted the paddle back into the clamps and moved to the front of the pontoons. He grabbed the nylon straps at the front of the craft with one hand and reached for the woman with the other.

  His awkward, rubber mitts slipped off her head, her shoulder.

  He tried again.

  On his third attempt, he snagged a hank of hair and pulled her toward the craft. Scooping his hands under, he coaxed her torso to rotate.

  Her face tilted skyward.

  Pale skin. Blue lips. White eyes staring into the overcast sky.

  Lund’s legs started to shake.

  He couldn’t move. He couldn’t think. He could only stare.

  His wife had died two years ago. Her body burned until there was nothing left but shattered bone and ashes.

  And yet here she was, staring up at him from the icy water, her beautiful face frozen in a scream.

  Chapter

  Two

  To say Val Ryker was worried would be a vast pile of understatement.

  Arriving at the lake, she marched past the vacant swing set and down the pea gravel trail. She worked her right hand as she walked, flexing and stretching, trying to coax feeling back into her fingertips, even though she knew it wouldn’t work. It never did.

  But that wasn’t what concerned her. Not right now.

  Her sergeant’s voice had sounded strained on the phone, unusual coming from a man only one degree more expressive than a brick wall. And although he refused to give details, she’d ducked out of the village’s Christmas tree lighting ceremony as soon as Grace had finished her solo and raced to Rossum Park, going as fast as she dared without lights and siren.

  A handful of volunteer firefighters milled at lake’s edge, along with Baker and Caruthers of the EMS. She didn’t want to talk to anyone, not until she knew what had prompted Olson’s call. Squinting into the wind, she scanned the lake until she spotted the sergeant’s towering bulk.

  Up to his knees in frozen green-brown grass and the naked spears of cattails, Olson waved her onto the ice, the motion stiff and abrupt. The sheen of sweat slicked his brow, yet his ears were red with cold.

  She picked her way across the slick surface. “Sergeant? What is it?”

  He looked up but didn’t answer, as if waiting for her to get closer.

  Unease lodged under her rib cage like a bad meal. The fire department’s ice rescue raft rested at Olson’s feet, neon orange, the trail where it had been dragged out of the open water, over ice and along the edge of the cattails reflected the gray sky.

  Then she saw the body.

  Female. Strapped to the front of the pontoon raft. Her head and shoulders propped up as if she was lounging on a pillow. She wore a pink coat and jeans and her mouth was open, as if taking a last gasp for breath. Worst of all, her skin held the pallor of frozen chicken and her hair stuck in an icy mat to the side of her face, obscuring her features.

  Val was aware of the call that had come into dispatch. A woman had fallen through the ice, drowned. It was a tragedy they’d failed to rescue her, but that didn’t explain why Olson had called her away from the Christmas tree lighting or what had made him so upset.

  “She’s dead,” he said, once Val reached him.

  “I can see that. She looks frozen solid. I wonder how long she was in the water before the call came in.”

  “She’s dead,” he gave her a pointed look, “for the second time.”

  “Come again?”

  “Take a look at her face. A good look.”

  Having started her career in the Chicago PD, Val had seen bodies before, more of them than she cared to think about.

  Even since she’d moved to small town Wisconsin, she’d had a few occasions to face death—people who refused to strap on their seat belts splattered across pavement, the depressed man who’d decided to clean his teeth with the barrel of a shotgun—but she had to admit, human popsicle was a new one.

  Preparing herself to face another death, Val leaned over the body.

  Beneath the frozen hair, the victim’s eyes were nearly as white as her skin, their original color nearly impossible to guess. But she was pretty. High cheekbones, full lips, and a mole on her right jaw.

  God help her.

  Val closed her eyes, then opened them, but the face remained the same. One she’d never forget. One that sent shudders through her, head to toe. “This isn’t possible.”

  Olson stepped beside her, pulled off his hat and rubbed a hand over the blond stubble he called hair. “Where has she been all this time? And who was the body in the barrel?”

  Questions she couldn’t answer.

  She let out a heavy breath that condensed in the air before being whipped away by the wind.

  About two years ago, she’d spent countless hours searching for Kelly Ann Lund, the thirty-three-year-old daughter of a local dairy farmer. After shards of her bones were discovered in the farm’s burning barrel, Val had spent countless more tracking down the man who’d murdered her and putting him in prison.

  And now Kelly Ann was staring up at them, not burned in the least.

  Olson finally broke the silence. “So much for DNA.”

  “Mito DNA,” she reminded. Unlike nuclear DNA, mitochondrial DNA wasn’t unique to one person, but to a maternal line. Passed down from mother to offspring, it could belong to any of Kelly’s maternal relations.

  Olson scuffed the ice with the toe of one boot. “She doesn’t have an evil twin, does she?”

  Val appreciated the attempt at levity, but she couldn’t manage a smile. A sergeant at the time, she’d been lead investigator on the case. The facts were burned into her memory. The bones recovered belonged to a female. The mito DNA indicated the victim was part of Kelly’s maternal line. And yet … “She had no siblings at all. No living maternal relatives. That’s why I was so sure it was her.”

  “We were all sure.”

  She gave Olson a grateful glance.

  “We need to call the chief.”

  She tried not to feel the sting of his words. “I’m the chief, Pete.”

  “Sorry. Schneider. We need to call Schneider.”

  Jeff Schneider had been a mentor, almost a father figure, to them both. Of course unlike Val, Pete had spent his entire career working his way up through the ranks of the tiny Lake Loyal PD. Val knew he’d assumed he would take over as chief when Schneider retired. The whole town had assumed.

  Then she’d arrested the brutal murderer of Kelly Ann Lund, and the job was hers—first female police chief of the village of Lake Loyal.

  She pulled out her cell phone.

  “He’ll know what to do,” Olson said.

  “I’m not calling Schneider. I’m calling Harlan.” At least this late in the afternoon, it wasn’t likely the coroner was up to his elbows in a dead body, not that that would faze the delusional old Casanova. “No point in moving forward until we have an official ID.”

  “Maybe we don’t have to get an ID.” Olson’s voice was so low, she could barely hear it over the wind. He squinted toward the shoreline. “I secured the scene as soon as she was brought in. No one’s gotten a good look at her. No one except Lund.”

  “David Lund?”

  “He was the one who towed her in.”

  She glanced toward shore and spotted Kelly’s estranged husband for the first time. He sat a few feet from the truck, one hip hitched up on the edge of a playground structure, cradling a steaming foam cup in his hands. He still wore the neon yellow suit the firefighters used for ice rescue. Hood peeled back, he watched them, the wind ruffling his dark, wavy hair.

  “I know it’s a crazy idea. Probably stupid. That’s why we need to talk to the chief.”

  Val forced her focus back to Olson. “What idea?”

  “Like I said, no one else has seen her. No one knows it’s Kelly.” He stared straight at Val, as if willing her to understand. A muscle along his jaw flexed.

  “Pete ...”

  “We
say we can’t ID her, not local, fell in the lake.”

  “I don’t think you should say anything more.”

  “You don’t think Kelly ending up in the lake is an accident, do you? That she just happened to be strolling over ice so thin even the most rabid ice fishermen haven’t put up a single shanty?”

  She didn’t have to glance around to note the public park and forest preserve, the upscale houses rimming the lake, the Shoreline Supper Club overlooking the expanse of water and ice. The park was well used in the summer, but even in winter, a number of people walked area trails and gazed out over the beautiful vista.

  Not to mention the fact that an officer checked Rossum Park in the afternoon and once after midnight on routine patrol. Kelly hadn’t been in the water during the midnight check, not that the officer could see. But in the light of day, there she was. “Obviously she was supposed to be found,” Val said.

  “And the one person it helps is serving time in Waupun. You know what’s going to happen as soon as his lawyer hears we found Kelly’s body.”

  She knew. Her head pounded with it.

  Guilty verdicts weren’t something one could transfer from body to body like a change of clothing. She’d arrested Dixon Hess for killing Kelly Lund—the witness seeing them together, rumors of an affair, her blood in his truck; that was the evidence that tied him to those charred bones. Without Kelly as the glue, Val’s whole case disintegrated.

  “Forty-eight hours. That’s all we’ll have,” Olson said.

  She felt sick to her stomach. About Kelly Ann’s death, about the prospect of a killer going free, about the fact that Olson could even suggest they decimate every ethical standard and break the law themselves to fight back. “We’ll make our case, but we’ll follow the law.”

  “We don’t even have a fucking clue who he burned.” Olson looked away and took several breaths. Turning back, he lowered his voice. “Our job is to serve and protect the people of Lake Loyal. You think letting a monster loose is the way to go about that?”